, ,

A discussion about depression- an interview with Seth Gillihan

Image from: www.highlandhosp.com

This week I interviewed Dr. Seth Gillihan, a clinical assistant professor of psychology at the University of Pennsylvania. He has published books on managing anxiety, depression, and OCD, and is the author of Think, Act, Be, which features the articles he’s written on depression. I chose to interview Dr. Gillihan because of his extensive work with depression and to ask what it was like to study depression on a professional level. My interview also included the question of how both living with depression affected his life as well as his career. After all many of those interested in studying psychology suffer from depression or face other mental conditions, and worry that it may stop them from pursuing their interests. I hope this interview helps such people and shows them that they can continue to follow what they love without such worries.

 

What led you to study CBT (cognitive behavior therapy), anxiety, and depression?

I was drawn to anxiety and depression because they seemed like conditions I could understand. I actually didn’t know at the time how much I could relate to them—I wasn’t aware of my own struggles in these areas back then. But I think anyone knows what it’s like to feel anxious or to feel down, so we can kind of extrapolate to get a sense of what a true anxiety disorder or major depression is like. That only gets you so far, of course. I don’t think you can really know what these conditions are like till you’ve experienced them yourself.
Once I knew the area I wanted to work in, I tried to figure out how I could be most helpful to people. When I was in my master’s program at GW I started hearing about something called cognitive behavioral therapy or CBT. The more I heard about it the more I was drawn to it. I liked that it was based on common sense principles that anyone could understand. I think it appealed to my science background since I was a Bio major in college and never took any psych courses. I also had a professor at GW who strongly influenced my direction, encouraging me to get advanced training in CBT in my doctoral program. So I only applied to PhD that had a strong CBT emphasis, which led me to Penn where I did the rest of my training.
 What motivates you to write about depression and anxiety?
I guess two things. I write about these topics because frankly I feel like I have a good sense of what it’s like to experience them. I got involved in this field almost 20 years ago because I wanted to be helpful to people in some way. I’d always imagined that work would be one-on-one, doing therapy. The possibility of helping more people through things I write is very rewarding.
I also enjoy the process of writing. I’ve been writing since I was a kid. Back then I guess it was what you’d call early fan fiction—new adventures of the A-Team, mostly. I wrote a lot during graduate school and when I was a full-time faculty member at Penn and Haverford College. I was writing book chapters and journal articles, which is a tonof work and unfortunately very few people end up reading it. Even people in my field probably just read the abstract for the most part. To be honest when I looked at my CV it seemed like most of the publications I had didn’t serve much of a purpose, other than filling lines on my CV.  I wanted to write things that people would read and find useful.
I don’t find it particularly easy to write, which is probably part of why it’s rewarding. I like trying to translate things into words that’ll resonate with someone and either give them a tool for managing what they’re dealing with or a bit of inspiration to keep going. So I try to pass along helpful ways of dealing with depression and anxiety, and encourage people to keep fighting, to treat themselves kindly, to find ways to connect to things that bring them a sense of meaning. We tend to do better in every way when we’re living a life we care about. 
How long have you been studying depression and do you think you’ve found anything to help the way society views depression?
I started studying depression around 2000, so I guess it’s been about 17 years now. In the beginning I was studying what was already known about depression, especially the risk factors and the treatments that work well. In graduate school and beyond I was doing my own research to try to understand what causes depression and how we can prevent it. Now I’m back to being a consumer of research.
It’s an interesting question about finding something to help society’s view of depression. It seems like for about as long as people have been getting depressed there’s been a kind of “othering” in the way we see it. Depression is supposedly something that “mental patients” get (by the way, “mental patient” is not a term I actually use).
I think it’s helping that there’s a lot more awareness now than there used to be, but we’ve still got a long way to go obviously. I hope that by sharing my own struggles I can help in a small way to normalize the experience—to say that this is something that can happen to pretty much anyone, given the right conditions.
I also feel a responsibility to expose some of the myths about how depression should be treated. Not everyone who’s depressed needs formal treatment, and not everyone who gets treatment needs medication. The idea that depression is a “chemical imbalance caused by low serotonin” has been debunked, but that idea has lived on, making people think that medication has to be part of the treatment equation. Mild to moderate depression generally respond well to either therapy (like cognitive behavioral therapy) or medication (usually an SSRI like Prozac). More severe depression usually requires both therapy and medication.
How did depression affect your life, and if you don’t mind me asking, how long?
Thankfully the effects on my life were rather subtle, although that’s probably why it took me a while to recognize it. So I’m not really sure how long it lasted. Probably several months, and maybe as long as a year or two in a mild or “sub-threshold” form.
I think it made it harder to do some things, just finding the motivation for activities outside of my daily responsibilities. It probably led me to drink more alcohol, although at the time I don’t think I realized my mood was having that effect. It probably contributed to some problems sleeping, but it’s been a while now so I don’t remember for sure.
The most obvious effect was on the way I saw myself. I really didn’t like myself at that time. I knew my friends and family seemed to like me, but it was hard for me to imagine why. I was pretty disgusted with myself, and really for no good reason. A lot of the time I had a sense that the people who knew me had a vague feeling of dislike for me, which seems to have been entirely a product of my depressed imagination. It’s easy to see how it could have gotten a lot worse if I hadn’t seen the depression for what it was. Thankfully I had really great support from my wife and close friends, which made all the difference.
 Do you have any advice for someone with depression who wants to go into the same field?
For anyone going into a field like clinical psychology, I’d want them to think about what draws them to that field. Is it primarily to be helpful to others? To “fix yourself”? Maybe some combination of the two? There’s not necessarily a wrong reason to go into this field, but it helps to know why we’re doing it.
Some really good treatments have come from psychologists’ own struggles. I’m thinking of Marsha Linehan’s DBT and Steve Hayes’s ACT. I’m guessing there are many more cases of people who used their own issues to develop effective treatments.
Regardless of what we might be dealing with, it’s really important to know it won’t get in the way of our effectiveness as a therapist. It doesn’t matter if it’s depression or anxiety or an autoimmune condition—whatever it is, you don’t want it to be a significant barrier to being helpful.  
Obviously we all have things we deal with. I may not have been as effective as a therapist right after each of our kids was born and I was getting less sleep than usual. Those kinds of things are unavoidable parts of being human. But if we’re impaired to the point where we really can’t carry out our work responsibilities, or we’re so deep in a depression that we’re not able to concentrate or think clearly, then the clinical care we provide is really going to suffer. So we owe it to ourselves and to the people we serve to be as healthy as possible, and to know when we’re not able to function effectively. But I certainly wouldn’t think depression rules someone out from being a therapist. I guess I’m proof of that.
I would also say use your experience with depression—or any struggles you have—to make you a better therapist. Let it deepen your compassion for people in pain. If your heart’s going to be broken, let it break in the service of others.
I am very thankful to Dr. Gillihan for this interview and I hope that you enjoyed it. If you want to know more about his works, click here.

15 Comments

Leave a Reply
  1. I really likes the beginning, it was a very nice intro. Maybe for your questions, only bold the questions, the bold and underline is almost too much and kind of distracting from the article. When reading the whole article, I didn’t find a hook to keep me reading.
    I was kind of wondering if you just used the transcribed version of the interview because if you did I would consider annotating the interview so that you can help readers become interested and understand what the interviewee is meaning. Overall, I love the questions you asked, the structure could use a bit work though.

  2. I liked the story format that was employed for this interview. It really humanized the interviewee and the effects of depression. Furthermore, I think the humanization accomplished what the article was intended to accomplish, lifting some of the worry people suffering from depression have about being able to pursue their dreams.
    There were a few grammatical mistakes here and there, but a little bit of proofreading could easily remedy that, and it didn’t take away much from the content that was being delivered. However, I feel like the interview would have been even more informative if there was a more in-depth analysis and/or discussion of the causes of depression instead of simply stating that it’s rather common. Although, I do also feel that the manner by which the interviewee discussed the variety of treatments and levels of depression allows the reader to recognize that depression is much more complex than it’s usually portrayed in our culture.

  3. This is a really good topic to discuss, as it’s a well-needed discussion in our society today. I thought the article was well structured and interesting, and the questions were certainly intriguing. The introduction was very effective at introducing the topic and source of the information being discussed. I liked how you separated the questions from the answers through both underlining and bold, as it helped the words pop and be set apart from the other words. Overall a good read with a well-structured discussion and good flow.

  4. Informative article and intriguing. As someone who suffered from major depression and is interested in the field of psychology, I feel this is an important topic. Many people suffer from depression across all cultures so its a great area to research on. I do have to say in the second question, there was a typo “which is a tonof work and unfortunately very few people end up reading it.” I think it’s supposed to read “a ton of work”. Other than that great work!!

  5. I love reading articles that discuss the experiences of an individual who has actually suffered from mental illness, rather than just another psychologist talking about something they only have secondhand experience with. The questions you asked were thought-provoking not only for me, but also for Dr. Gillihan (based on his long responses). My main suggestion in the future would be to include information in the introduction other than what you asked the interviewee in the interview. We have the article to find out what you asked Dr. Gillihan, so maybe the introduction would be better served with more information about the interviewee or the subject being discussed.

  6. A very well written article. As a person who is severely diagnosed with crippling depression, I couldn’t agree more. Most people would think people with depression would start hurting themselves, but that is not the point at all.
    We don’t do it for the fun of it.
    We don’t do it for attention.
    We don’t do it as an “easy way out”.
    It’s refreshing to see someone articulately expains, understands and sees that depression is more than just “being sad” because most people think that it is nothing more than that.

  7. Like many others who commented, I appreciate how personal this interview was and how the writing style reflected that. There is a time and a place for a more personal and story-like writing style, and this was one of those. The author asked Dr. Gillihan many more intimate questions about his life and his depression, so a story-like approach was a good option.

    I was very happy to read about Dr. Gillihan’s views on treatment for depression and other mental illnesses. I am in agreement that medication, while a useful tool, is not the only treatment option. Sometimes you need it, sometimes you don’t, and other times you need medication and another treatment. Treatment is very personal and situation based, and I don’t think many people truly understand that.

    I do love how encouraging this interview is. I have been diagnosed with an anxiety and bipolar disorder and often times find myself discouraged by that fact. But Dr. Gillihan’s message of pursue your dreams while keeping yourself healthy was incredibly helpful to read, especially coming from someone who has experienced these same struggles.

  8. I enjoyed this article greatly because I felt like in comparison to other interviews, it was very informative yet personal. It almost felt like I was reading a story (in a good way) so I was very interested and kept reading. I appreciated how Dr. Gillihan was able to share his own experiences and maybe its because he is a writer but I felt like the way he spoke was very eloquent. It is amazing to see how someone with the issue is able to make a change and research on it and get a Ph.D in the field. I think this is great because this is the best way to get good results because the person has personally been affected by it. I think this also could make the person more passionate about making a difference which is great. I really liked the one like where Dr. Gillihan says, ” If your heart’s going to be broken, let it break in the service of others.” He doesn’t try to tell the reader what to do or discourage anyone, but says that it is okay to do this. This was a great read!

  9. I liked how this article connected depression to Dr. Gillihan’s experiences. It was interesting to see what motivated him to become a psychologist, and that the problems of different people who become psychologists can lead to effective therapies.

  10. A stunning interview in a really hot topic. I loved the way the article went on, not to mention a very powerful introduction to have a quick view about the interview. The article was an interesting one to read and have I only one comment, I wish the interviewee “Dr. Gilihan” to have talked more about his experience with depression.

  11. I was able to really connect to this article – I, too, like Dr. Gillihan wrote fan fiction. In all seriousness, I loved the structure and format of this interview. The questions allowed us readers to associate with the discussion, as many readers can relate or sympathize to depression.

    Something I have begun to notice is that interviews do not really contain much evidence and results of research. We are getting the scientific discussion and thought provoking responses, but by reading through the actual data and an analysis of said data, us readers can understand the topic that much better. I really do like how the article was written though and I liked the singled out bold quotes.

    This article was great to read for readers interested in pursuing psychology, and I think that is many of them, it discusses motivation behind the decision to study. The only other thing I’d include is what Joanna mentioned before me, to include a way to help those with depression. How can we be a support system, or how do those with depression talk to someone to seek help?

  12. It was a well written article. I especially enjoyed the formatting of this interview, as well as the type of questions asked. It helped to make it a smooth read.

  13. What I like the most about this interview was the depth that the questions and the answers went into. It gave a good understanding of a personal account with dealing with depression as well as helping others with their depression. It also gave an account on how depression may not always be recognised. Also, Dr Gillihan suggested a method in going towards an area where one could study depression. Overall, it was a very informative read. Thanks!

  14. As a psychology student I worry that sometimes I may not be strong enough to pursue this career. This article comforted me that I am not alone and that to be a psychologist I don’t have to be a superhero. I think that is definitely a fear among other students that they are not allowed to be human in this process. This article proves that you don’t have to shut yourself off to be a psychologist. Thanks for the good read.

  15. I think this is a good article, there are alot people who think depression is only about cutting yourself. I think more people should be aware of what depression actually feels like, or what it feels like to feel anxious. If youre interested in helping someone you know who’s down, this could be very helpful.

    I’d like to read what Dr. Seth Gillihan’s partner and friend did to cheer him up, so other people can help their friends/family out.

    I think i’ve never experienced a depression, but i know what it feels like to dislike yourself, don’t feel like doing things you used to enjoy and stop seeing friends. Its a very lonely experience.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Transforming Ordinary People into Killers: The Tutsi Genocide- and Interview with Dr Scull

A discussion about depression- an interview with Seth Gillihan